返回   华枫论坛 > ◆生活板块◆ > 汽车天下

查看投票结果: 下面 2010 compact SUV 你会选哪个?
2010 Honda CR-V LX 4WD 4 23.53%
2010 Toyota Rav4 Base 4WD 5 29.41%
2010 Toyoto Rav4 Base 4WD V6 7 Seat 9 52.94%
多重选择投票。 投票者: 17. 您不可以参加此投票



发表新主题 回复
 
只看楼主 主题工具
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 20:06   只看该作者   #21
zhezhejj
Senior Member
级别:35 | 在线时长:1425小时 | 升级还需:15小时级别:35 | 在线时长:1425小时 | 升级还需:15小时级别:35 | 在线时长:1425小时 | 升级还需:15小时
 
注册日期: May 2006
帖子: 304
zhezhejj is an unknown quantity at this point
默认

引用:
作者: bigzozo 查看帖子
假设一样的价格,
CR-V V4 2.4L LX 4WD
Rav4 V4 2.5L Base 4WD
Forester 2.5X

dealer 给的2010新车价格(含税)是CR-V LX 4WD $27000,Rav4 Base 4WD
$27000....
Rav4 V6 Base 4WD with third row seating 2010 dealer 给的价是$30500 真的含税价吗?价格不错啊,在GTA吗?
zhezhejj 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 20:11   只看该作者   #22
entrylevel
Senior Member
级别:3 | 在线时长:28小时 | 升级还需:4小时级别:3 | 在线时长:28小时 | 升级还需:4小时级别:3 | 在线时长:28小时 | 升级还需:4小时
 
注册日期: Apr 2010
帖子: 145
声望: 0
entrylevel is an unknown quantity at this point
默认

引用:
作者: 老兵不死 查看帖子
这是个最大的误区.

SUBARU有很好的AWD系统.这没错.但是SUBARU的车却有高低之分的.类似于FORESTER这样的低端车,其AWD系统不过是电子控制的TRACTION CONTROL而已.

SUBARU对AWD的宣传类似于VOVOL对安全性的宣传,都是小车厂以某个特色来吸引买家...
何以见得Forester用TRACTION CONTROL,而Rav4和CRV就用好的AWD?只能同价位的车比较。另外,大众车就一定比小众车好吗?
entrylevel 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 21:00   只看该作者   #23
alones
Senior Member
级别:9 | 在线时长:130小时 | 升级还需:10小时级别:9 | 在线时长:130小时 | 升级还需:10小时级别:9 | 在线时长:130小时 | 升级还需:10小时级别:9 | 在线时长:130小时 | 升级还需:10小时级别:9 | 在线时长:130小时 | 升级还需:10小时
 
注册日期: Mar 2008
帖子: 210
声望: 0
alones is an unknown quantity at this point
默认

都不怎么样,我就买1万左右的二手车。
新车只有开15年才划算,3万的车平均一年2千。我买1万的车开5年,5年后扔了再买。
alones 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 21:13   只看该作者   #24
Envy
欧阳费劲
级别:23 | 在线时长:624小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:23 | 在线时长:624小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:23 | 在线时长:624小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:23 | 在线时长:624小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:23 | 在线时长:624小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:23 | 在线时长:624小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:23 | 在线时长:624小时 | 升级还需:48小时
 
Envy 的头像
 
注册日期: Jul 2006
帖子: 1,533
积分:6
精华:2
声望: 72458373
Envy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond reputeEnvy has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: e39m03 查看帖子
我喜欢修车换零件的感觉...

上周把车身上前门的两条 weather seals (老化, 褪色, 裂缝) 换掉, 关门后密封的感觉又跟当初新车一样.

两条价格: $60 x2 = $120
时间: 1 hour (第一次推挤的不够, 不能全塞进去, 花了两倍的时间, 第二条不到 10...
你是喜欢DIY的,当然没问题。

大部分人是不喜欢DIY的或忙的没时间等等,害怕2手车买到手就得大修,其实没啥问题你大修啥呢?到手最多全身检查一下做到心中有数就成,到期需要更换的部件如皮带在买的时候就可以问清楚。安全前提下,需要更换的部件在安检的时候就更换完了,不然安检也过不了,这类担心是不必的。真能遇到有大问题的概率很小,不放心找个看车师傅帮忙就是。

LZ经济不稳定仍花钱买新车,觉得陷入误区,风险加大,就多提醒几句,不要匆忙做决定。

Envy 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
感谢 Envy
此篇文章之用户:
bigzozo (Sep 14th, 2010)
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 21:20   只看该作者   #25
蓝魔
Senior Gear
级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时
 
蓝魔 的头像
 
注册日期: Jan 2008
帖子: 10,896
积分:66
精华:18
声望: 2341126
蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: Envy 查看帖子
你是喜欢DIY的,当然没问题。

大部分人是不喜欢DIY的或忙的没时间等等,害怕2手车买到手就得大修,其实没啥问题你大修啥呢?到手最多全身检查一下做到心中有数就成,到期需要更换的部件如皮带在买的时候就可以问清楚。安全前提下,需要更换的部件在安检的时候就更换完了,不然安检也过不了,这类担心是不必的。真...
我也不是什么时候都有时间去 DIY 的,比如上次换 BMW 530i 的四条减震和周边的零件时,就花了 $500 让别人去做,我实在不敢自己去做压缩弹簧的事。

新车其实贵,不管是多差的新车,头几年的贬值很厉害。花了很多钱,如果不满意的话,卖出去至少一年亏 $3000-$4000。这个钱还不如拿出一点用来维修二手的。

所谓的大修只要不是引擎和传动出了大问题,就都是小修,一次不过几百,而且车就那么多零件,换过的不会再需要换。就算是引擎和传动出了问题, 如果其它部分运作良好,花几千快有时候也值得。

Never argue with an idiot. He will consistently drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.
蓝魔 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 21:25   只看该作者   #26
老兵不死
步兵班长
级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时
 
老兵不死 的头像
 
注册日期: Mar 2008
帖子: 2,820
积分:34
精华:9
声望: 111877630
老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: entrylevel 查看帖子
何以见得Forester用TRACTION CONTROL,而Rav4和CRV就用好的AWD?只能同价位的车比较。另外,大众车就一定比小众车好吗?
SUBARU的恒时四驱系统(前后轮永远都会被分配动力),只用在某些车型如WTI,OUTBACK上面.
2010的FORESTER采用前轮驱动系统配以电子感应的ON DEMAND四轮驱动系统,和RAV4类似,都是在感应到打滑时才分配动力到后轮

三个车里AWD最差的是CRV,用的是液力藕合式四轮驱动系统,反应最慢

老兵不死,他们只是慢慢凋零
老兵不死 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 21:56   只看该作者   #27
NDT70
Senior Member
级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时
 
注册日期: Mar 2005
帖子: 2,524
声望: 2042882
NDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: 老兵不死 查看帖子
SUBARU的恒时四驱系统(前后轮永远都会被分配动力),只用在某些车型如WTI,OUTBACK上面.
2010的FORESTER采用前轮驱动系统配以电子感应的ON DEMAND四轮驱动系统,和RAV4类似,都是在感应到打滑时才分配动力到后轮

三个车里AWD最差的是CRV,用的是液力藕合式四轮...
我一直以为SUBARU都是全时四驱,试驾过森林人,没有象RAV4那样的两驱四驱转换。
刚才又看了下关于2010森林人的介绍,感觉应该是全时四驱的
An honest-to-goodness SUV with a number of un-SUV-like qualities, the Subaru Forester brings an unexpected balance of desirable attributes for a truly unsurpassed level of driving confidence. Go ahead and forge a new path courtesy of Forester's powerful yet efficient SUBARU BOXER engine and world-renowned Subaru symmetrical full-time All-Wheel Drive (AWD). A low centre of gravity and generous ground clearance enable the Forester to climb higher but corner flatter. Surefooted all-wheel drive handling is complemented by reassuring class-leading safety ratings. And the harmonious arrangement continues: An available Multimedia Option equips the Forester with the latest technology, including a Bluetooth® hands-free system and GPS DVD-based navigation, for the ultimate in convenience at your fingertips. Whether you choose to get adventure-ready with the new 2.5X Outdoor Package or PZEV Outdoor Package; stay connected with the new value-packed Sport-tech model or indulge yourself with the 2.5X Limited Package or the high-performance turbocharged Forester 2.5XT Limited, there's plenty of rugged SUV capability and stylish comfort that's thoroughly fun for any outing.

想法多,希望少
NDT70 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 22:12   只看该作者   #28
NDT70
Senior Member
级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时
 
注册日期: Mar 2005
帖子: 2,524
声望: 2042882
NDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

我在阿省,一年里有半年会下雪,所以我会首选森林人。试驾过森林人,sport-tech上路价3万4包括17寸胎天窗导航什么的,内饰实在一般,DEALER说这车冬天可以不用雪胎。
CR-V好像是要开始打滑2秒以后才能挂上4驱,如果在高速上,2秒内能发生很多事情,只能自求多福了。
NDT70 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 22:47   只看该作者   #29
FC-1
Senior Member
级别:8 | 在线时长:96小时 | 升级还需:21小时级别:8 | 在线时长:96小时 | 升级还需:21小时级别:8 | 在线时长:96小时 | 升级还需:21小时级别:8 | 在线时长:96小时 | 升级还需:21小时
 
注册日期: Jul 2004
帖子: 250
声望: 1460008
FC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond reputeFC-1 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: NDT70 查看帖子
我在阿省,一年里有半年会下雪,所以我会首选森林人。试驾过森林人,sport-tech上路价3万4包括17寸胎天窗导航什么的,内饰实在一般,DEALER说这车冬天可以不用雪胎。
CR-V好像是要开始打滑2秒以后才能挂上4驱,如果在高速上,2秒内能发生很多事情,只能自求多福了。
我的经验是4驱在速度快时用处是不大的, 速度快时对刹车没什么帮助, 认识个渔友专为钓冰鱼从美国买了森林人, 冰上积雪时操作确实很愉快,但结果有次401下雪踩刹车急了点横转了几圈就下了路涯子,非常惊险,还好人没事.

我在安省, 和一帮朋友最爱钓冰鱼, 去的很多都是整个冬天不扫雪的地方或湖面, 4驱最大用处是能比较容易让你从雪地里脱困
FC-1 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 23:09   只看该作者   #30
bigzozo
Member
级别:3 | 在线时长:26小时 | 升级还需:6小时级别:3 | 在线时长:26小时 | 升级还需:6小时级别:3 | 在线时长:26小时 | 升级还需:6小时
 
注册日期: Sep 2010
帖子: 32
声望: 0
bigzozo is an unknown quantity at this point
默认

引用:
作者: zhezhejj 查看帖子
Rav4 V6 Base 4WD with third row seating 2010 dealer 给的价是$30500 真的含税价吗?价格不错啊,在GTA吗?
I am in Alberta. With HST of Ontario, the on-road price would be higher.
bigzozo 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 23:40   只看该作者   #31
NDT70
Senior Member
级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时
 
注册日期: Mar 2005
帖子: 2,524
声望: 2042882
NDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: FC-1 查看帖子
我的经验是4驱在速度快时用处是不大的, 速度快时对刹车没什么帮助, 认识个渔友专为钓冰鱼从美国买了森林人, 冰上积雪时操作确实很愉快,但结果有次401下雪踩刹车急了点横转了几圈就下了路涯子,非常惊险,还好人没事.

我在安省, 和一帮朋友最爱钓冰鱼, 去的很多都是整个冬天不扫雪的地方或湖面, ...
冬天四驱和雪胎一样只是改善驾驶性能,并不能绝对保证安全。我去年第一次用雪胎,第一场大雪后以为有了雪胎就和平时一样快到停牌前才踩一脚刹车结果车停不下来越过停牌滑到路中间才停下来。
NDT70 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 14th, 2010, 23:59   只看该作者   #32
老兵不死
步兵班长
级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时
 
老兵不死 的头像
 
注册日期: Mar 2008
帖子: 2,820
积分:34
精华:9
声望: 111877630
老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: NDT70 查看帖子
我一直以为SUBARU都是全时四驱,试驾过森林人,没有象RAV4那样的两驱四驱转换。
刚才又看了下关于2010森林人的介绍,感觉应该是全时四驱的
An honest-to-goodness SUV with a number of un-SUV-like qualities, the Subar...world-renowned Subaru symmetrical full-time All-Wheel Drive (AWD).
这个所谓的FULL TIME AWD有很大的迷惑性.

SUBARU本身的四轮驱动系统有几个不同的类型.其中一种是恒时四驱,用于高端的OUTBACK车型上.高端这个是50:50分配,然后CENTRE differential可以根据需要最多达到80:20动力分配.而低端则采用电子感应的ON DEMAND的工作方式.低端的这个在MPT不工作时,前后动力分配为90:10(相当于在普通驾驶状态时是两轮驱动)

其中最本质的区别一个是通过differential工作,而一个是用multi-plate transfer clutch来工作.

从驾驶感觉来说,也会有所不同.FORESTER的驾驶感觉会很类似于前驱车.

此帖于 Sep 15th, 2010 00:25 被 老兵不死 编辑。
老兵不死 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 15th, 2010, 00:10   只看该作者   #33
老兵不死
步兵班长
级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时
 
老兵不死 的头像
 
注册日期: Mar 2008
帖子: 2,820
积分:34
精华:9
声望: 111877630
老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute
默认 下面的文章可能过分专业了.但是可以比较清楚的解释

下面的文章可能过分专业了.但是可以比较清楚的解释SUBARU不同的AWD系统.

如果真的有兴趣搞清楚各种系统间的区别,就认真的读一下吧.

不过,其实对大多数买车人来说,都不会太关心的.因为厂商已经用其宣传策略让消费者以为他们买到的是一样的东西了.

There is a lot of confusion about the differences between the various Subaru AWD systems:
Continuous (for 5MT)
Active (for 4EAT)
VTD (for 5EAT)
availability or non-availability of Rear LSD
So heres an attempt to explain the differences....

1. Continuous AWD System:

The manual transmission’s all-wheel drive is referred to as a continuous all-wheel drive system. It uses a center differential located inside the transmission case that is controlled by a viscous coupling device. In effect, the center differential is a limited-slip differential.

In normal operation, power is distributed equally to the front and rear wheels. Plates are alternately attached to the front and rear output shafts inside the viscous coupling. When a rotational difference occurs between the front and back wheels, the plates inside the viscous housing shear inside the contained fluid (a type of silicone) heating it and causing the fluid to thicken. The thickened fluid causes the plates to transfer torque from those that rotate faster (the slipping wheels) to the plates that rotate slower (the wheels with the best traction).

This no-maintenance system is simple, compact and virtually invisible in its operation. The system can distribute torque from a 50:50 torque split for maximum traction to mostly front or rear wheel drive.

(Source: http://www.autoworld.com/news/Subaru..._All-Wheel.htm)

A. Continuous AWD with Rear LSD: Available with 5MT on WRX, Legacy GT, Outback 2.5i, Outback XT and with 6MT on Spec.B

B. Continuous AWD without rear LSD: Available with 5MT on Impreza 2.5i, Outback Sport and Legacy 2.5i


2. Active AWD System:

Active all-wheel drive is a term coined by Subaru to differentiate the all-wheel drive system in the automatic transmission (4EAT) from other "reactive" all-wheel drive systems on the market today. What makes this all-wheel drive system so special is its ability to anticipate traction needs and act before a wheel slips.

The mechanism that transfers torque fore and aft is contained within the transmission’s tailshaft. To the casual observer it looks just like a typical hydraulic clutch found in any automatic. The key difference in this clutch pack is its operation. It’s designed to slip according to how much all-wheel drive is needed. When an automatic’s clutch slips, it is due to a malfunction and will eventually burn up. But the multi-plate transfer (MPT) clutch uses a special friction material that easily withstands the friction loads generated during torque transfer. (Also referred to as VTC = Variable Transfer Clutch)
The MPT’s operation is controlled by the Transmission Control Unit (or TCU) and constantly changes dependent on how the vehicle is being driven. To get more all-wheel drive, the TCU increases the hydraulic pressure to the clutch for less slippage. Less all-wheel drive calls for more slip and the TCU reduces the hydraulic pressure to the clutch.
Under normal, dry pavement operation torque split is about 90% front and 10% rear. This distribution helps to compensate for the car’s weight distribution and resultant smaller effective rolling diameter of the front tires. As weight transfers to the rear of the vehicle, (i.e., under acceleration), the TCU shifts the torque split more toward the rear wheels. Under hard braking, torque is directed forward. Torque distribution is changed based upon how the vehicle is being driven. Throttle position, gearshift lever position, current gear and other factors combine to influence the TCU and it, in turn, selects a software map that determines how aggressively torque split will be adjusted.
Two speed sensors are used by the TCU to detect wheel slippage. One sensor monitors the front axle set, the other the rear axle set. Pre-programmed variables help the TCU differentiate between slipping wheels and normal wheel speed differentials as what occurs when cornering. A speed differential (front-to-rear) of up to 20% signals the TCU that the vehicle is cornering and torque is distributed to the front wheels to help increase traction during the turn. Anything above 20%, however, indicates to the TCU that wheel slippage is occurring and torque is then distributed to the rear wheels.
Another feature of the all-wheel drive system is its interaction with the anti-lock brake system. When ABS is engaged, the transmission selects third gear, reducing the unpredictability of engine braking and, thus, reducing the possibility of wheel lock-up. But all four wheels are still connected to the engine through the AWD system and are brought back up to overall vehicle speed quicker and can, therefore, be controlled again sooner. In a two-wheel drive system if the locking wheel isn’t a drive wheel, it can only be brought back up to overall wheel speed by whatever traction exists between it and the road. The quicker a wheel is controlled the better the stopping performance

(Source: http://www.autoworld.com/news/Subaru..._All-Wheel.htm)

A. Active AWD with Rear LSD: Available with Outback 2.5i

B. Active AWD without Rear LSD: Available with 4EAT on Impreza 2.5i, Legacy 2.5i, Legacy 2.5i Ltd


3. Variable Torque Distribution (VTD):

It has the MPT (multi plate transfer) clutch aka VTC as found in the Active AWD system but it also has a planetary-type center differential and a Rear LSD. The center differential provides the ability to have a default torque split of 45/55 front/rear (as against the 90/10 split in Active AWD). In every other aspect it is similar to the Active AWD in that it anticipates wheel slippage instead of reacting to it as in the case of a MT. We can say the the VTD is an advanced Active AWD system

Available with 4EAT on Impreza WRX
Available with 5EAT on Outback XT, Outback 3.0R, Legacy GT


4. Driver Controlled Center Differential (DCCD):

Uses an electronically managed multiplate transfer clutch and a mechanical limited-slip differential in conjunction with a planetary gear-type center differential to control power distribution between the front and rear wheels. Normally, DCCD splits power 41% front and 59% rear. Sensors monitor parameters such as wheel slippage, steering angle, throttle position and braking to help determine torque distribution and direct it to the wheels with optimum traction. DCCD also features a helical-type limited-slip front differential and a Torsen® limited-slip rear differential.

Available with 6MT on Impreza WRX Sti


Does my Subaru have a Rear LSD?

Another point of confusion is which Subarus have Rear Limited Slip Differentials (Rear LSD) and which ones do not. For this you can refer to the list of Subaru AWDs above where I have also listed the Subaru models which have that type of AWD. But to make things even clearer heres a list of Subarus with and without Rear LSD:


Subarus without Rear LSD:

Impreza 2.5i (5MT and 4EAT)
Outback Sport (5MT and 4EAT)
Legacy 2.5i (5MT and 4EAT)
Legacy 2.5i Ltd. (4EAT)

Subarus with Rear LSD:

Impreza WRX (5MT and 4EAT)
Outback 2.5i (5MT and 4EAT)
Outback XT (5MT and 5EAT)
Outback 3.0R (5EAT)
Legacy GT (5MT and 5EAT)
Spec.B (6MT)
WRX Sti (also has Front LSD)



As we all know that the center differential can split the torque in between the front and the rear axles depending on the front/rear wheel slippage. But its the Front and the Rear LSDs which can split the power between left and right wheels. So it is very advantageous to have at least the Rear LSD if not the Front LSD. If the left rear wheel slips the Rear LSD can transfer the power to the right rear wheel.

Subaru does not offer Rear LSDs in its lower models except in Outback 2.5i!! which is understandable since it is designed for off-road conditions. (This might explain the mpg difference in Outback 2.5i and Legacy 2.5i)



Which is Better?

Now that brings us to the next point of debate as to which one is better?

So here's an excerpt from an article I found:

(Source: http://www.cars.com/carsapp/cars/?sr...all_wheel.tmpl)

"Simpler AWD systems “bias” the power to the front or the rear in this way and react to slippage when it occurs. Subaru's “continuous” AWD system is this type. More advanced systems are designed to be proactive rather than reactive. For example, Subaru’s “active” AWD is claimed to anticipate and prevent slippage for a seamless driving experience. Audi's quattro and related Volkswagen 4MOTION AWD systems route power based on vehicle dynamics: Rear tires have greater grip during acceleration, so during that action the rear wheels receive more of the engine’s power. In turns, the outside front wheel has the most grip and thus gets the most power, followed by both rear wheels.

With advanced AWD like this available on cars such as the Porsche 911 Carrera 4, it’s clear that four driven wheels are no longer the province of high-ridin’ mud buggies. For surefooted handling during acceleration — even on bone-dry roads — AWD is tough to beat."

As per the author of this article the Continuous AWD system found on Subarus with 5MT and 6MT is a simpler system in that it is more reactive than proactive. Whereas the Active AWD systems (with Variable Transfer Clutch) found on 4EAT Subarus and the VTD (which is an advanced Active AWD system) found on 5EAT Subarus are proactive in predicting wheel slippage conditions and hence react faster. But obviously the Continuous AWD systems have the advantages of being less complex and hence less prone to failures and low repair costs.


So again which system is the best? I would say the order could be as follows:


DCCD with Front and Rear LSDs - WRX Sti
VTD - 4EAT on WRX and 5EAT on Outback XT, Outback 3.0R and Legacy GT
Active AWD with Rear LSD: 4EAT on Outback 2.5i
Tie. Depends on what you need more? proactive AWD system or the Rear LSD (if offroading)
Active AWD without Rear LSD: 4EAT on Impreza 2.5i, Legacy 2.5i and Legacy 2.5i Ltd
Continuous AWD with Rear LSD: 5MT on WRX, Legacy GT, Outback 2.5i, Outback XT and 6MT on spec.B
Continuous AWD without Rear LSD: 5MT on Impreza 2.5i and Legacy 2.5i

Subaru saves its best AWD system for the Impreza WRX Sti which has the DCCD system with front and rear LSDs.

I wasnt aware that the Outback 2.5i has the Rear LSD. Thats an advantage over the Legacy 2.5i.
老兵不死 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
共 4 位会员
感谢 老兵不死 发表的文章:
bumpkin (Sep 15th, 2010), mili (Sep 25th, 2010), NDT70 (Sep 15th, 2010), 寒竹 (Sep 15th, 2010)
旧 Sep 15th, 2010, 00:16   只看该作者   #34
老兵不死
步兵班长
级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时
 
老兵不死 的头像
 
注册日期: Mar 2008
帖子: 2,820
积分:34
精华:9
声望: 111877630
老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

SUBARU也不是唯一这么做的厂商.比如大众,也有类似的不同的AWD系统.只不过大众会用不同的名字,叫做4 MOTION和QUATTRO.
老兵不死 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 15th, 2010, 01:12   只看该作者   #35
NDT70
Senior Member
级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时
 
注册日期: Mar 2005
帖子: 2,524
声望: 2042882
NDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: 老兵不死 查看帖子
Subaru saves its best AWD system for the Impreza WRX Sti which has the DCCD system with front and rear LSDs.
...
Impreza(四门Sedan基本型起价20995)的介绍
For instant and seamless response to varying driving conditions, the optional 4-speed Electronic Direct Control Automatic Transmission with Manual Mode allows the driver to shift gears manually or choose from two fully automatic modes (Normal and Sport). The multi-plate transfer clutch AWD system maintains a 60/40 torque split (front/rear) for more predictable handling and automatically adjusts up to a 50/50 split under hard acceleration or when conditions warrant.

森林人(基本型起价25995)的介绍
Forester models equipped with the 4-speed Automatic Transmission with SPORTSHIFT® use a multi-plate transfer clutch limited-slip centre differential. This allows the driver to choose from two fully automatic modes (Normal and Sport) and a manual-shift SPORTSHIFT® mode. The AWD system maintains a 60/40 torque split (front/rear) and automatically adjusts up to 50/50 split under hard acceleration or when conditions warrant.

WRX STI(四门Sedan基本型起价32495)的介绍
The 2011 WRX STI's multi-mode DCCD (Driver Controlled Centre Differential) allows for the adjustment of the electromechanical centre differential to ensure precise handling in all conditions. The Auto mode is for all-around driving; torque distribution automatically varies between 41/59 and 50/50 (front/rear) as conditions warrant. By tightening the centre differential, the Auto [+] mode enhances traction and stability on slippery roads, targeting a 50/50 torque split, front/rear. The Auto [-] mode targets a 41/59 (front/rear) torque split for enhanced turning capability and more responsive handling. Lastly, Manual mode offers the driver a 6-step adjustment of the centre differential locking.

看起来Impreza和森林人平时都是60/40的力矩分配,根据需要可以自动调整到50/50,而且森林人有防滑中央差速器。
DCCD好像是让司机来选择逐级锁定中央差速器或通过自动调整分配前后轮的力矩。
NDT70 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
感谢 NDT70
此篇文章之用户:
寒竹 (Sep 15th, 2010)
旧 Sep 15th, 2010, 11:32   只看该作者   #36
老兵不死
步兵班长
级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时
 
老兵不死 的头像
 
注册日期: Mar 2008
帖子: 2,820
积分:34
精华:9
声望: 111877630
老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

引用:
作者: NDT70 查看帖子
Impreza(四门Sedan基本型起价20995)的介绍
For instant and seamless response to varying driving conditions, the optional 4-speed Electronic Direct Control Automatic Transmission with Manual Mode allows the driver to shift gears manually or choose from two fully automatic modes (Normal and Sport). The multi-plate transfer clutch AWD system maintains a 60/40 torque split (front/rear) for more predictable handling and automatically adjusts up to a 50/50 split under hard acceleration or when conditions warrant.

森林人(基本型起价25995)的介绍
Forester models equipped with the 4-speed Automatic Transmission with SPORTSHIFT® use a multi-plate transfer clutch limited-slip centre differential. This allows the driver to choose from two fully automatic modes (Normal and Sport) and a manual-shift SPORTSHIFT® mode. The AWD system maintains a 60/40 torque split (front/rear) and automatically adjusts up to 50/50 split under hard acceleration or when conditions warrant.

WRX STI(四门Sedan基本型起价32495)的介绍
The 2011 WRX STI's multi-mode DCCD (Driver Controlled Centre Differential) allows for the adjustment of the electromechanical centre differential to ensure precise handling in all conditions. The Auto mode is for all-around driving; torque distribution automatically varies between 41/59 and 50/50 (front/rear) as conditions warrant. By tightening the centre differential, the Auto [+] mode enhances traction and stability on slippery roads, targeting a 50/50 torque split, front/rear. The Auto [-] mode targets a 41/59 (front/rear) torque split for enhanced turning capability and more responsive handling. Lastly, Manual mode offers the driver a 6-step adjustment of the centre differential locking.

看起来Impreza和森林人平时都是60/40的力矩分配,根据需要可以自动调整到50/50,而且森林人有防滑中央差速器。
DCCD好像是让司机来选择逐级锁定中央差速器或通过自动调整分配前后轮的力矩。...

我不太清楚你的资料是从哪里来的.它肯定了在低端的车型上,SUBARU采用了不同类型的AWD系统(multi-plate transfer ),但是动力分配的问题上我觉得却搞错了.

我在SUBARU的官方网站上无法找到对其AWD系统的详细介绍,但是找到了下面的话:

Active All-Wheel Drive
Models equipped with 4-speed automatic transmission utilize an electronically controlled variable transfer clutch to distribute power where traction is needed. Sensors monitor parameters such as wheel slippage, throttle positions and braking to help determine torque distribution and direct it to the wheels with optimum traction.

里面没有提到动力分配的比例,但是肯定了它是一个Active的系统.

此帖于 Sep 15th, 2010 11:57 被 老兵不死 编辑。
老兵不死 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 15th, 2010, 11:48   只看该作者   #37
蓝魔
Senior Gear
级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时级别:66 | 在线时长:4709小时 | 升级还需:48小时
 
蓝魔 的头像
 
注册日期: Jan 2008
帖子: 10,896
积分:66
精华:18
声望: 2341126
蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute蓝魔 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

multiplate transfer clutch 才是真正高性能的 LSD, 前, 中, 后都有机械 LSD 的才是王者.
蓝魔 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 15th, 2010, 11:55   只看该作者   #38
NDT70
Senior Member
级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时级别:56 | 在线时长:3451小时 | 升级还需:26小时
 
注册日期: Mar 2005
帖子: 2,524
声望: 2042882
NDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond reputeNDT70 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

Impreza
http://www.subaru.ca/WebPage.aspx?We...ebSiteID=282#1

Forester
http://www.subaru.ca/WebPage.aspx?We...ebSiteID=282#1

WRX & WRX STI
http://www.subaru.ca/WebPage.aspx?We...6036&Range=WRX %26 WRX STI&ModelYear=2011&WebSiteID=282

前两个看的都是自动挡的,WRX好像没有自动挡的。
NDT70 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 15th, 2010, 12:06   只看该作者   #39
老兵不死
步兵班长
级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时级别:33 | 在线时长:1253小时 | 升级还需:39小时
 
老兵不死 的头像
 
注册日期: Mar 2008
帖子: 2,820
积分:34
精华:9
声望: 111877630
老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute老兵不死 has a reputation beyond repute
默认

在美国的官方网站上.FORESTER不同的TRIM采用了不同的系统:

http://www.subaru.com/content/static.../features.html
老兵不死 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
旧 Sep 16th, 2010, 20:19   只看该作者   #40
jackhu
Member
级别:5 | 在线时长:47小时 | 升级还需:13小时
 
注册日期: Jul 2004
帖子: 55
声望: 0
jackhu is an unknown quantity at this point
默认

应该是税前价。去年同型号最后价是$35000.

引用:
作者: zhezhejj 查看帖子
Rav4 V6 Base 4WD with third row seating 2010 dealer 给的价是$30500 真的含税价吗?价格不错啊,在GTA吗?
jackhu 当前离线  
回复时引用此帖
感谢 jackhu
此篇文章之用户:
zhezhejj (Sep 16th, 2010)
发表新主题 回复


发帖规则
不可以发表新主题
不可以发表回复
不可以上传附件
不可以编辑自己的帖子

启用 BB 代码
论坛启用 表情符号
论坛启用 [IMG] 代码
论坛禁用 HTML 代码



所有时间均为格林尼治时间 -4。现在的时间是 14:25

请尊重文章原创者,转帖请注明来源及原作者。
凡是本站用户自行发布的任何信息,皆不代表本站的立场,
华枫网站不确保各类信息的正确性和可靠性,也不承担由此而导致的任何直接或间接损失以及任何法律责任。

Copyright © 1999-2024 Chinasmile