【讨论】泱泱大国居然因为换牙而不能容忍一个天真无邪的小姑娘上台歌唱祖国，用假唱。

[sage]

没这么夸张。帕瓦罗帝的告别演唱会也是lip-synch的。

[sage]

作者: 星手

帕瓦罗帝lip-synch的刘欢唱的歌？还是谁的？

自己的。他的经济人痛心疾首。不过这有什么吗？不影响他一代歌王的成就。老了唱不动了而已。big deal!

不明白干嘛揪住这个细节不放呢？现在国外好多记者也看到这个报道了，越发地添油加醋，他们本来就对中国心怀叵测。

[sage]

作者: aaronding

那是自己的声音。这次这个是双簧。

So? 有本质上的区别吗？电影还有配音呢。本来就是一台Show。

[sage]

作者: 举目有亲

唉，那一刻眼泪差点夺眶而出，原来是show，张导，不愧为戏子也。

不受影响啊，我的感动总是真实的。哪次奥运没有煽情的节目？
大家要求太高了吧？

[sage]

作者: cbitmap

这样的安排，两个小孩未必高兴。当然我这只是猜想了，因为如果是我的话，我很不高兴。

几千个孩子中挑出来的两个，会不高兴吗？

愤怒的选手们真是春节得搞笑，那你们相信reality tv是reality吗？

[sage]

作者: pebloy

这是一场show， 本意不是为了让谁出名， 让谁不出名。

站在台前与唱在台后， 对这个show来说地位是平等的。 那些无名的志愿者乐巅乐颠跑前跑后， 那些啦啦队员一蹦就是两三小时， 要说不尊重， 对她们来说也不够尊重呢， 谁知道她们是谁啊。

好好的一场show一扯上名利就完全变了味。

同意！

大家要求太高了。就是一台Show而已。宽容点。老谋子策划这么一台节目不容易，能出错的地方太多了，结果几近完美地演绎出来。能不能让人享受两天成功后的欢乐？

[sage]

作者: 星手

不象电影、戏本来大家就知道是假的。

星子妹妹真可爱！
这出戏跟别的戏有什么不同呢？观看的人多了点？同步直播？

[sage]

作者: aaronding

大家有嘲笑电影的配音和电脑特技吗？

你怎么反着说呢？这逻辑。

[sage]

作者: 星[B

手[/B];2531760]还有假死、假伤？

刘欢形象也差还有那女黑，那得多少钱啊，听说就饭店1天10000，还算便宜。干脆也叫两个英俊、漂亮的男女摆在那。反正我觉得是大败笔。

faint! 原来认错人了。
不好意思。

[sage]

看看这老外写的文章估计就没那么愤了。

Tuesday, August 12, 2008 6:56 AM by will
Why I don't care about the opening ceremony's fraudulent footprints
Or so you would start to believe from the press reports over the last day. Some have dwelt upon the lip-synched singing of hyper-precious Lin Miaoke, the impossibly apple-cheeked munchkin girl who "sang" the laudatory and self-referentially titled "I sing for my motherland" without toppling over in shock at the thought of being watched live by 90,000 people and countless millions on live television. She must have been on ketamine, because I would have frozen like fudge in Fargo. And I generally have no problem with public speaking.

More reports have focused on the somewhat more scandalous replacement of the "giant footprints" fireworks display with a computer-generated special effect.

Here is what Imagethief thinks of both of these revelations: So what?

I got news for you: Li Ning wasn't really flying either. If they'd really wanted him to fly they would have shot him out of an air cannon in a flaming suit and he could have lit the torch as he sailed over it and out of the stadium into the Great Beyond of the Olympic Green.

Damn, forget Zhang Yimou. With ideas like that, I oughtta plan these events.


The Olympic opening ceremony may have represented many things, but "veracity" was not among them. I thought it was a pretty good show. But let's face it: it packaged Chinese culture as vulgar burlesque and reduced the legendary 5000 years of history to arena-rock light show. The whole thing was one giant special effect from beginning to end. But I don't care. I like vulgar burlesque and arena-rock light shows. This was my kinda show!


In fact, arguably Olympic Beijing, tarted up, hyper-sanitized, stripped of automobiles and resolutely micro-managed for two weeks, is something of a colossal special effect in and of itself. Among all this surely one digital process shot can be forgiven.

Even the Olympics themselves can be thought of the same way. Overmarketed, pompous, awash in idiotic pseudo-religious symbolism (remenber the "priestess"-infested torch lighting ceremony?), and rife with doping and age scandals, they're certainly a yard or two from what most of us would consider "reality". It's well off the deep-end of showbiz, and showbiz is all about illusion. And I write all of this as someone who's relatively excited about the games! But you have to be clear-eyed about these things.


The only grudge I hold about the footsteps is that it was a particularly cool idea. I even said, "That's cool!" to Mrs. Imagethief while we were watching it on the immense TV that my landlord so graciously installed in my apartment. So, yes, I was fooled. My bad. But I was still entertained by the shot, which is more than can be said for the oxygen-destroying tedium of the totally un-retouched parade of national teams. If anything, I could have used a little less veracity there. (On that note, NBC denies editing the parade to make the US team come out later in the US broadcast. Imagethief suggests that the turgid pace of the parade simply made it seem like eternity before the US team came out.)

As for munchkin girl, of course she was lip synching. While we were watching her I turned to Mrs. Imagethief and said, "The munchkin is lip synching." This doesn't make me a genius. It simply makes me someone who grew up watching Superbowl halftime shows, the Grammy Awards, and other lip-synch classics.
In fact, on that note, and overlooking the two hour Grand March of Tedium and my various bitchy comments above, I give the opening ceremony pretty high marks. The first part was legitimately spectacular, and I enjoyed the finale as well. Yes, I think Zhang and the Gang could have done themselves a favor and left out the footprints if they didn't think it would work. Or simply taken their chances on the helicopter chase. But I'm sure they were all biting their nails to quick during the entire four hour extravaganza already. Has anybody tracked sales of Tums (or the Chinese equivalent) in Beijing over the past month?

In fact, the soporific parade aside, the only other things I'd have voted to remove from the ceremony were the absurd hand-doves of peace, the goose-stepping soldiers and slow march of the Olympic flag around the entire circumference of the field in the statium. The soldiers kindled unpleasant associations for many foreigners, and the flag march simply came way too late in the show for such draggy self-indulgence.

But good marks on the whole. I'd say that the London 2012 crew (remember, there will be another Olympics after this one, assuming the sun doesn't explode) has its work cut out for them. Imagethief has just one bit of advice for them: Keep it under two hours. At four hours, the Beijing ceremony was longer than the Oscars (speaking of fraudulent). Keep it short, leave 'em wanting more. Everyone will love you for it. Or at least I will.

And that's gotta be worth something, right?
source: http://news.imagethief.com/blogs/chi...ootprints.aspx

[sage]

作者: cbitmap

要真的没错，国内为什么开始封杀这条新闻了？因为自己都觉得难看。

共产党一贯地愚蠢！比如西藏暴乱，让外国记者进去报道呗，总有人会公平地说话。这次也是，让大家讨论呗，有什么的，不就是一场表演吗。